id: PIR-2026-0014title: IBM Automated Order Taking voice AI removed from more than 100 McDonald's drive-thrus at the end of a roughly two-year test marked by reported order errorsdate_occurred: 2021 through 2024-07-26 (a test begun with IBM in 2021, described in the reporting as roughly two years, ending with the 2024-07-26 shutdown)date_detected: ongoing (viral customer error videos peaked mid-2023; analyst reports flagged underperformance from 2022)date_disclosed: 2024-06 (termination communicated to franchisees by internal memo; reported 2024-06-13/17)status: corroborated (company statements to press + franchisee memo + multiple independent outlets)agent_description: IBM Automated Order Taking (AOT) - voice AI taking live drive-thru orders and entering them into the order system at 100+ US McDonald's locations, with restaurant crew as backstop. Lineage: McD Tech Labs (Apprente acquisition), sold to IBM in 2021 with the AOT partnership.operator_type: enterprise (McDonald's franchise locations; IBM-operated stack)autonomy_level: human-on-the-loop (crew monitored and corrected orders)model_stack: IBM AOT voice stack; model details unknownharness: drive-thru audio + POS/order-entry integration; details unknownauthority_scope: external comms (converses with customers), data access (writes orders into the order system). No direct funds authority; billing errors flowed through mis-entered orders.funds_at_risk_usd: unknown (per-order error exposure small; the program investment is the material write-off, never disclosed)blast_radius: customers/third parties (drive-thru customers at 100+ locations)root_cause: plain-error (primary; speech recognition/comprehension errors in production; no adversary, no malfunction beyond wrong judgment)failure_locus: agent-reasoning (perception/transcription); vendor-operated model stack, so model-provider contributesexploitation_status: in-wild-malfunction (real malfunction against real customers, no adversary; originally recorded as bare "in-wild" because no v0.1 enum value cleanly fit a non-adversarial malfunction - the gap this v0.2 token closes)mechanism: Over the test, the voice agent was reported to mishear and mis-enter real orders: viral videos showed bacon added to ice cream, hundreds of dollars of McNuggets stacked onto one order, and simple orders confused, forcing crew intervention. Insiders cited trouble with accents; analysts reported franchisees found the tech "underwhelming." These are the reported evidence of poor performance; McDonald's did not publicly give them as its reason for ending the test. McDonald's ended the IBM partnership (announced to franchisees June 2024) and removed the technology from all test locations by 2024-07-26, while stating voice ordering remains part of its future plans.adversary_present: no (some viral clips involved customers deliberately confusing the bot, but no security adversary)severity: degraded (persistent service degradation and program abandonment; no acute loss event)direct_loss_usd: unknown (the multi-year, 100+ store test written off; figures never disclosed)indirect_loss_usd: unknown (crew intervention labor; reputational cost of viral error videos)downtime: n/a (system removed permanently by 2024-07-26)data_exposure: none reportedcontrols_that_worked: human crew backstop caught and corrected mis-entered orders (bounded per-customer harm to annoyance); pilot scoping to ~100 of ~13,500 US locations bounded the blast radiusdetected_by: operator (internal performance data) + third-party (viral customer videos, analyst reports)time_to_detect: n/a (continuous, known degradation - analyst reports from 2022)time_to_recover: n/a; program terminated rather than fixedremediation: IBM partnership ended; AOT shut off at all test locations by 2024-07-26structural_fix: none within the system; McDonald's shifted to evaluating other voice-ordering vendors (separate Google Cloud partnership continued)telemetry_grade: none (no operator telemetry public; evidence is company statements, franchisee memo reporting, and customer-shot videos)sources:independence: all third-party press, corroborating the same company statements; error-severity evidence is customer-generated video.aiid_incident_id: 475 (https://incidentdatabase.ai/cite/475/) - cross-reference; primaries verified independentlyconfidence: high on termination, timeline, and scale (company-confirmed, multiple outlets); medium on error severity/frequency (viral videos and insider accounts, no disclosed accuracy metrics - the weakest link)aiid_incident_id cross-reference (AIID 475), matched against the AIID weekly database export (2026-08-17). A cross-reference, not a re-verification; no claim changed.See also - this event in the AI Incident Database: incident 475.